Lake Erie Island Gems

Landmark & Quiet Coast
Perry’s Victory and International Peace Memorial is a landmark that defines the island, offering a stunning bird’s-eye view and fascinating peek into the past. Yet, Massie Cliffside Preserve is becoming its own staple attraction. This 11-acre sanctuary offers a fishing dock and trails that wind right to the edge of the limestone bluffs, offering a rugged, quiet beauty many tourists miss.

Ancient History & Modern Adventure
Walking the catwalks above the Glacial Grooves at Kelleys Island provides an awe-inspiring glance into geological history. But for those who want to get their boots dirty, the East Quarry offers a trail network that winds through a fossil-rich, almost lunar landscape, complete with sweeping sights of Horseshoe Lake you can’t get from the road. “I think a lot of people sleep on the Horseshoe Lake area,” Bauer says. “There’s beautiful views there.”

Local Hangout & Private Party
The Village Pump anchors Kelleys Island’s social life. Famous for fresh perch and legendary Brandy Alexanders, it’s a bustling hot spot filled with island energy. For a totally different pace, visit Kelleys Island Wine Co. Complete with a cantina serving Mexican fare and a massive courtyard for horseshoes and volleyball, it feels less like a bar and more like a private estate party.

Pool Party & Perfect Pizza
Middle Bass Island offers an escape at J.F. Walleye’s, a reliable neighborhood hangout with a lagoon pool and can’t-miss walleye bites. But the best-kept secret is hidden inside the Middle Bass General Store. While it looks like a convenience store, the kitchen cranks out some of the islands’ best pizza. With a fully stocked bar, patio seating and MBI souvenirs, it’s a one-stop shop for authentic island vibes.

Crowd Pleaser & Culinary Secret
Sitting on the upper deck of Put-in-Bay’s The Boardwalk with a steaming bowl of lobster bisque and view of the harbor is a rite of passage that never gets old. But venture away from the waterfront, and you’ll find a different kind of magic at The Forge. Tucked into a renovated blacksmith shop, this spot offers savory crepes, garden-to-glass cocktails and a sophisticated, slowed-down vibe that feels like a secret garden party compared to the high energy of the strip.

Nature Museum & Lake Lab
The Lake Erie Islands Nature & Wildlife Center is PIB’s premier stop for budding naturalists, providing a look at the region’s fauna with indoor wildlife displays, a turtle pond and nature trails. For hands-on discovery, take the crew to the Aquatic Visitors Center, which turns the lake into an interactive laboratory and includes live displays of its ecosystem. “It’s a super fa mily-friendly spot similar to an aquarium,” says Jill Bauer, public relations manager for Shores and Islands Ohio. “It offers free admission and hands-on fishing experience. [Kids under 16] can fish for free and whatever they catch, they bring into the facility for the day so everyone can see it.”

Classic Vines & Local Flavors
A ferry ride to Pelee Island has always meant relaxation at the Pelee Island Winery pavilion. It is the classic lawn-chair-and-wine-tasting experience that anchors the island’s tourism. But Stone House 1891 has elevated the scene. Located right by the ferry dock, this craft kitchen brings a farm-to-table ethos to the island. With a stunning patio and a menu that highlights local ingredients, it provides a chic, culinary bookend to your trip.